Which Dog Chew Is Best? A Guide to Bison, Beef, Lamb, Chicken & Elk Antlers

A Guide to Bison, Beef, Elk, Lamb, Chicken — and Elk Antlers

Which option is best for my dog?

Bison, beef, lamb, chicken, and elk antlers all serve different purposes. Some are edible chews, meant to be consumed, while others — like elk antlers — are long-lasting gnawing chews designed for enrichment and dental engagement.

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. The best choice depends on your dog’s size, chewing style, sensitivities, and how you plan to use the chew.

Why chew type and protein choice matter

Not all chews work the same way. The animal source — and whether the chew is edible or non-edible — affects:

• How long the chew lasts

• How rich or lean it is

• Digestibility and tolerance

• Whether it adds calories or is mainly for enrichment

Single-ingredient chews make this easier because you always know exactly what your dog is chewing.

Bison: Lean, simple, and gentle

Best for:
Dogs with sensitivities, dogs needing a leaner option, and dogs who do well with simpler proteins.

Bison is naturally lean and highly digestible. Because it’s less commonly fed than beef or chicken, many dogs tolerate it well. Bison chews are satisfying without being overly rich, making them a good everyday option.

• Fat level: Lean

• Chew type: Edible

• Chew time: Medium

• Flavor: Mild

Beef: Rich and long-lasting

Best for:
Most dogs, especially strong chewers who enjoy a hearty chew.

Beef chews are rich, flavorful, and highly satisfying. They tend to last longer than leaner options and are often a favorite for dogs who go through lighter chews too quickly.

• Fat level: Rich

• Chew type: Edible

• Chew time: Long

• Flavor: Bold and familiar

Beef may not be ideal for dogs with known sensitivities, but for many dogs it’s a reliable classic.

Lamb: A balanced alternative

Best for:
Smaller dogs, moderate chewers, and dogs sensitive to beef or chicken.

Lamb sits between lean and rich. It’s often well tolerated and provides a satisfying chew without being as heavy as beef. For many dogs, lamb is a helpful alternative protein.

• Fat level: Medium

• Chew type: Edible

• Chew time: Medium

• Flavor: Rich but not overpowering

Chicken: Easy and familiar

Best for:
Puppies, seniors, and light chewers.

Chicken is one of the most familiar and easily digestible proteins for dogs. Chicken chews tend to be lighter and less dense, making them easier to chew and break down.

• Fat level: Lean

• Chew type: Edible

• Chew time: Short to medium

• Flavor: Mild

Because chicken is a common allergen, it’s best avoided if your dog has shown sensitivity to poultry.

Elk Antlers: Long-lasting gnawing chews

Best for:
Power chewers, dogs who love to gnaw, and dogs who go through edible chews quickly.

Elk antlers are not edible chews like meat-based treats. They are naturally shed antlers designed for slow gnawing over time, providing enrichment and dental stimulation rather than calories.

Elk antlers are:

• Extremely long-lasting

• Low-odor and low-mess

• Naturally rich in minerals

• Not consumed in one sitting

Important considerations:

• Best for experienced chewers

• Not recommended for puppies or dogs with dental issues

• Always choose the appropriate size and supervise use

• Chew type: Gnawing (non-edible)

• Chew time: Very long

• Purpose: Enrichment and dental engagement

Quick comparison guide

Should you rotate chews?

Many dog owners rotate chews to:

• Prevent boredom

• Match different chewing needs

• Avoid overfeeding one protein

Rotation can be as simple as alternating between edible chews and longer-lasting gnawing options like antlers. When rotating edible chews, it’s best to change proteins gradually and observe how your dog responds.

Our approach to simple, honest chews

We believe dog chews should be straightforward and transparent. That’s why we focus on single-ingredient options, responsibly sourced and made in the USA, with minimal processing and no preservatives or additives.

Knowing exactly what you’re giving your dog makes it easier to choose what works — and to adjust when their needs change.

Final thoughts

The best chew for your dog depends on how they chew, what they tolerate, and what role the chew plays in their routine. Some dogs thrive on edible chews like beef or bison, while others need the long-lasting engagement of an elk antler.

By choosing single-ingredient chews and matching them to your dog’s needs, you can chew with confidence — and let your dog enjoy what they do best. 

Ready to try? Browse our selection of single-ingredient treats and chews and treat your dog to a healthy, long-lasting chew today.